Category Archives: Accessibility

Three low white pillars glow with light while one person leans over each, pressing a button on the right side of each pillar releasing a unique scent.

Accessible Exhibition Guide: Delivering Content to All

When the user is included in the design process from the start, choices multiply for everyone’s benefit.

In Cooper Hewitt’s newest exhibitions, Access+Ability (through September 3, 2018) and The Senses: Design Beyond Vision (through October 28, 2018), designing with the user and visitor at the center are integral. Accessibility and inclusion are a key focus of these current exhibitions and essential strategic goals for the museum, now and for the years ahead. There are many exciting ways we’re stepping up our efforts even more and aiming to provide all audiences the same quality of experience on campus and online. https://www.cooperhewitt.org/accessibility-at-cooper-hewitt

In The Senses, visitors are welcomed into a multisensory playground touching, smelling, hearing, and seeing in dynamic and new ways.

Four adults are lined along and facing a curving wall covered in black synthetic fur. They stand on a wooden floor with backs facing outward as the each touch the wall moving both hands along and around the wall's surface.

Visitors touching a furry wall activate orchestral musical compositions. Designed by Studio Roos Meermanand KunstLAB Arnhem

While preparing for the exhibition we knew that there would be many touchable objects and installations (43 to be exact) in The Senses. What we lacked was the medium to deliver the exhibition content to every visitor. Cooper Hewitt’s Pen offers agency and a new way to explore in a museum for people who are sighted but without audio, how might visitors with low vision and who are blind explore the content?

Making Cooper Hewitt Content Accessible
In 2017, we launched our large print label feature on our collection website. This system makes available each exhibition’s label content (text and image) responsive to the user’s device and customizable in six different font sizes. Our Visitor Experience team also has an efficient way to produce large print label binders, directly from our collection database, for the galleries to share with visitors. We began investigating solutions for making content labels and gallery cues readable for people who are blind. We considered Braille labels, using beacon notifications, and even floor mats in front of each object and installation to message that an interaction is calling. Asking questions such as “which text would be more meaningful to print in Braille on the labels—object tombstone (museum-speak for object stats) or text about the object?” Wrong questions! All of this research and internal discussion wasn’t leading to viable solutions. Our group of five sighted colleagues, good intentioned as we were, weren’t getting at what the user might want. It was during a gallery visit with Sina Bahram—computer scientist, consultant, and researcher and President and Founder of Prime Access Consulting (PAC), which advises museums and other institutions on website and digital accessibility—who was onsite for meeting when he simply said “Identification and verification.” So obvious but somehow we weren’t seeing it! Every visitor wants agency to determine what information to access, about which object, when he or she wants it.

White label displays a bright yellow textures bar that messages touch | hear in Braille. Also printed in Braille are the object ID number that the user will enter into the app.

Accessible Exhibition Content Design

The Scaffolding
Using our API and label rail system—designed for access to the collection in the galleries—we determined the identification would be an assigned object ID number e.g. 0103, and verification is why we have the name of the object in Braille as well. This way, once you type the number of the “identified” object into your phone you can “verify” that you’ve got the right one in front of you. An added benefit since users can choose if they even want to read more about that particular object. An app could call the API and deliver the exhibition content. After discussing with our colleagues we prototyped, tested, and moved forward—with about 15 days to go before exhibition opening—to develop a version 1 native app for iOS with v.2 web-based application for android use.

Cooper Hewitt Accessible Exhibition Guide printied in white type on black background about a blank box where the keypad below is used to type in content ID number. HELP appears in top right corner.

Content number entry screen for Coper Hewitt app.

Accessible Systems
Bahram and Joshua Lerner of Monorail built the app. The tactile labels were produced by Steven Landau, whose company Touch Graphics creates accessible audio and tactile graphics. Every label in The Senses features an object title and number, printed in braille and Latin characters. Smartphones are used to access the associated content. Labels are discoverable as they are installed at a consistent height throughout the exhibition on our label rail system. Cooper Hewitt’s first Accessible Exhibition Guide was uploaded and went live on April 18. Download it from the Apple App Store or connect from our website. The guide contains the exhibition’s descriptive and interpretive content in both text and audio formats. A visitor can choose to read the text, hear it with a screen reader, or listen to an audio recording.

From top down: Black background with drop-out white type: 0104, Dialect for a New Era, 2017–18; Image of six glowing white pillars; label text.

Image of screen that appears when Dialect for a New Era content ID is entered into the app.

The Cooper Hewitt Accessible Exhibition Guide was conceived as we looked for multi-modal channels for content delivery for users with differing abilities. Designing for multiple senses highlights that the methodology of access not dictate level of access, which is the goal for the Accessible Content Guide and for Cooper Hewitt.

Large-print labels are live!

Launching alongside the long-awaited Jazz Age exhibition, the exciting new large-print label feature on our collection site is a key part of Cooper Hewitt’s ongoing accessibility initiative.

The original goal for the large-print labels project was to create a physical manifestation of our exhibition label content that could be distributed to museum visitors by our Visitor Experiences team upon request. Graphic designer Ayham Ghraowi, one of our 2015 Peter A. Krueger summer interns, worked closely with Micah Walter and Pamela Horn, director of Cross-Platform Publications, to design and develop a prototype application, the Label Book Generator. This prototype, built with Python using the Flask framework and originally hosted on Heroku, produced printable label booklets that met the museum’s standards for accessibility. This prototype was the first big step toward providing an accessible complementary experience of exhibition content for our visitors with low vision.

This fall, using the CSS stylesheets that Ayham developed for his prototype, Digital & Emerging Media experimented with a number of possible ways to deliver this large-print content to VE in production. Ultimately, we decided that rather than establishing a dedicated application for large-print label booklets, integrating the large-print labels into our collection site would be the best solution. This would not only allow us to rely on existing database connections and application code to generate the large-print label documents, but it would also corral all of our exhibition content under one domain, reducing any complications or barriers to discovery for VE and visitors alike. And by providing the label chats for each object, which are otherwise not included in any of our digital content, the large-print pages serve to supplement the main exhibition pages for our website visitors as well, adding a deeper layer of engagement to both the web and in-gallery experiences.

As of today, when a user visits any exhibition page on our collection site or main website, they’ll see a new option in the sidebar, inviting them to view and print the exhibition labels. The large-print page for each exhibition includes A-panel text alongside all available object images and label chats. If an exhibition is organized into thematic sections, this is reflected in the ordering of the large-print labels, and B-panel text is included alongside the section headers.

To generate these pages, I created a new exhibitions_large_print PHP library, which leverages the existing exhibitions, objects, and exhibitions_objects libraries to assemble the necessary information. Because we want to be able to print the large-print pages as one document for in-gallery use, our large-print pages cannot be paginated, unlike our main exhibition pages. This presents no issues for smaller exhibitions, like the ongoing Scraps. But very large exhibitions — like Jazz Age, for example, with over 400 objects — require way too much memory to be processed in production.

To get around this issue, I decided to assemble the large-print label data for certain “oversized” exhibitions in advance and store it in a series of JSON files on the server. A developer can manually run a PHP script to build the JSON files and write them to a data directory, each identified by exhibition ID. The ID for each oversized exhibition is added to a config variable, which tells our application to load from JSON rather than query the database.

https://gist.github.com/rnackman/8ed20dbfdc2962077c0b87975ca80e85

For greater flexibility based on individual needs, our large-print pages include clear and easy-to-locate UI tools for printing and adjusting font size. A user can select one of six default font sizes ranging from 18pt to 28pt, triggering some simple JS to reset the body font size accordingly. Internally, we can use the  pt query string parameter to enable large-print links to open the page with a specific default font size selected. For example, navigating to the large-print label page from an exhibition page using the Large Print sidebar icon opens the page at 24pt font.

https://gist.github.com/rnackman/84b10e7c4c862d128f58140f8adae75b

Visitor Experiences has prepared a number of printed large-print label booklets for our Jazz Age exhibition, available upon request at the front desk. Visitors may also print this document at home and bring it along with them, and any individual can access this responsive page on their desktop or mobile device.

We’ll be keeping an ear out for suggested improvements to this feature, and we’re excited to see how our visitors are engaging with these large-print labels on the web and in the galleries!

In addition to launching the large-print label pages, we’ve added an accessibility link to our header and footer navigation across all our sites, where visitors can learn more about the growing list of access services that Cooper Hewitt offers alongside large-print label booklets.